Remembering Favorites

[unoduetre]

Ha ha. Just a side note. It still makes me laugh when I remember that many anitubers ignored bunny girl senpai bacause of the bunny girl in the title.

[lolin]

I couldn't get into Nadesico myself. Didn't watch more than 3 episodes of it.

That's okay, it's got a pretty strange vibe to it, but it did manage to break a few tropes in its day.

[Momogari]

Nadesico made me remember Gundam. And oh yeah Macross.

Gundam 00 is in my top 20.
Gundam Seed is in my top 20.
Gundam UC is in my top 20.
AGE was great but probably not enough to rank here. Same with Iron-Blooded Orphans. I don't remember Turn-A enough to say, but I know I really liked it. 08th MS Team I really liked but I don't remember it well.

Macross....actually I have to be careful with Macross. Hella fun to watch, but was it objectively good? Fuck let's leave it off for now.

[Momogari]

Fuck it I hate to praise it because the loli is troublesome but Made in Abyss was incredible. It's probably top 20. Ugh.
If I'm going to throw in things primarily for artistic value, then I must consider Children of the Whales. Probably top 30, anyway.

Fullmetal Alchemist. Where does that stand. I like both the first anime series and Brotherhood roughly equally, but in terms of objective quality maybe Brotherhood is top 30 at least.

[Momogari]

Ha ha. Just a side note. It still makes me laugh when I remember that many anitubers ignored bunny girl senpai bacause of the bunny girl in the title.

Lol, I can imagine. Suckers.

[Momogari]

Let's see where I am right now...



Top 5
March Comes in Like a Lion
Shin Sekai Yori
*** ? ***
*** ? ***
*** ? ***

Top 10
Iroduku: The World in Colors
House of Five Leaves
Gundam Seed
Last Exile
SAO Alicization
*** ? ***
*** ? ***
*** ? ***

Top 20
Cowboy Bebop
Gurren Lagann
Gundam 00
Death Note
Twelve Kingdoms
Gundam UC
Made in Abyss
Rage of Bahamut: Virgin Soul
Kingdom
Naruto
Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju
*** ? ***
*** ? ***

Top 30 (overflowed by 1)
Carole and Tuesday
Black Lagoon
Samurai Champloo
Hisone and Masotan
Anohana
Arslan Senki
BECK
Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho
AICO Incarnation
Beast Player Erin
The Ancient Magus' Bride
Kino's Journey
Garo the Animation

Top 40 (overflowed by 2)
ERASED
Bokurano
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood
Re:Zero
Full Metal Panic: Invisible Victory
Chihayafuru
No Game No Life
Children of the Whales
Violet Evergarden
Haibane Renmei
Hakumei to Mikochi

top 53 (heh its not overflowed now)
Skip Beat
Yuri on Ice
Berserk
Claymore
Attack on Titan
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Knights of Sidonia
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai
Domestic Girlfriend
Now and Then, Here and There
Steins;Gate

So far there are 32 41 fuck it I lost count anime in my top 30.



EDIT: Let's try to reorder these

[unoduetre]

Let's copy-paste some from yours, ha ha.

My list keeps growing, ha ha.

[Momogari]

  Spoiler:  

Terror in Resonance
Serial Experiments Lain
Shin Sekai Yori
FLCL
Ghost in the Shell
Akira
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Cowboy Bebop
Samurai Champloo
Sailor Moon
Anohana: The Flower We Saw That Day
Death Note (excluding the ending)
Monogatari (many but not all of the series)
Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (but one MUST watch Fate/stay night first to get similar experience)
Iroduku: The World in Colors
Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai
Claymore
Domestic Girlfriend
Hellsing (both series (the first one and Ultimate), if I remember correctly Ultimate was better)
Your Name
Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood (I shouldn't put it in this list, because I read the manga and didn't see this one, but let's assume it's faithful to the manga
Bokurano
Tatami Galaxy
Erased
No Game No Life
Bleach (up to the end of the first main plotline)
Angel Beats
One Piece
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Gilgamesh
Re:Zero
Naruto (when I was younger)
One Punch Man
Chihayafuru
Made in Abyss
Angel's Egg
Kill la Kill
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Humanity Has Declined
Akame Ga Kill
Seraph of the End
World Trigger
Charlotte
Baccano!

Oh yeah on these:

Re:Zero
Chihayafuru (shit I just watched it too)
No Game No Life
Evangelion

Oh I still hadn't put Anohana in my list either.

I thought about World Trigger but I can't say it's objectively good enough for me. Or at least, if it was, I don't remember it.
I didn't think Charlotte was good enough for top 30. Or Owari no Seraph. Or Sailor Moon (sorry Naoki >3>)

[Momogari]

I wonder if Carole and Tuesday was top 30 too.

Shit I'd better stop thinking of this in terms of top 30. It's about to go into the 40's

[Momogari]

I just remembered Rage of Bahamut: Virgin Soul

I just put that into top 30 but I think that was top 20. I will change it.


Honestly Attack on Titan is good. It's top 30.

[lolin]

Fuck it I hate to praise it because the loli is troublesome but Made in Abyss was incredible. It's probably top 20. Ugh.
If I'm going to throw in things primarily for artistic value, then I must consider Children of the Whales. Probably top 30, anyway.

Fullmetal Alchemist. Where does that stand. I like both the first anime series and Brotherhood roughly equally, but in terms of objective quality maybe Brotherhood is top 30 at least.

FMA and Brotherhood are kinda weird for me because I vastly prefer the last 1/4 of the original and the first 3/4s of Brotherhood. Both are absolutely solid.

[Momogari]

original FMA ended kinda like an Arthur C. Clarke novel. Weird and kinda changing the entire feel of the story. But it was still a good ending and offered a good explanation and conclusion. Manga/Brotherhood (btw Uno yes Brotherhood was faithful to the manga. That was the point, after all) felt more natural and consistent all the way through and would have been better if they hadn't got too uppity and lost some of the fundamentals.



I've edited my list. I tried to break it out into groups up to top 50 while giving some room for insertions.

[Momogari]

I had to add Violet Evergarden and the Ancient Magus' Bride from uno's list.

[Momogari]

Oh, you added Vinland Saga. Hmm. It is pretty good...
No, I'm not convinced that gets on my list yet.
I'm not sure why actually. Just a feeling.

[Momogari]

Kino's Journey
Eromanga Sensei
My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei
WorldEnd: What do you do at the end of the world? Are you busy? Will you save us?

I agree that all of these had a lot of value. Eromanga Sensei was super surprising.

In terms of what I'm thinking of like objective value, I think for me I will only add Kino's Journey to my list.